Vikrant BEING FORCED to PRAISE Shanaya| Shanaya SELF PRAISING HERSELF with EXPRESSIONLESS ACTING

Shanaya Kapoor’s long-anticipated Bollywood debut has finally arrived, though not without its fair share of controversy and skepticism. Despite sharing screen space with talented actor Vikrant Massey, it appears that the focus of attention has been less on the film itself and more on Shanaya’s journey to the big screen. Much like many other star kids before her, Shanaya is now embroiled in the same age-old debate: is her story one of genuine struggle, or just another carefully curated narrative designed to appear relatable?

Shanaya Kapoor, daughter of actor Sanjay Kapoor and Maheep Kapoor, belongs to a powerful film lineage and is part of Bollywood’s elite inner circle. Her early connection to Karan Johar, who is often seen as the godfather of star kids, led many to believe that she would be launched under the prestigious Dharma Productions banner. Initially, she was meant to debut with a film titled Bedhadak under Karan Johar’s guidance. However, due to unexplained delays and Karan Johar’s rough patch with a string of flops at the box office, the film was shelved indefinitely. This led Shanaya to shift gears and accept other offers, eventually debuting in a different project.

In her recent interviews, Shanaya has spoken extensively about her “struggles,” highlighting how not being launched by Karan Johar set her apart from other star kids. However, this version of her journey is being heavily scrutinized. Critics argue that Shanaya’s situation was hardly one of struggle when viewed objectively. After all, even before her official debut, she had already signed multiple films, appeared in high-profile commercial advertisements for brands like Puma and Samsung, and remained in the public eye due to her elite social circle.

While her father, Sanjay Kapoor, never achieved massive stardom, Shanaya’s mother, Maheep Kapoor, played a critical role in keeping her daughter in the limelight. Maheep, part of Bollywood’s high society, was close to other influential families — from Shah Rukh Khan’s wife Gauri Khan to Chunky Pandey’s wife Bhavana. This gave Shanaya access to a network that most aspiring actors could only dream of. She attended school with Suhana Khan and Ananya Pandey, and the trio’s public appearances often drew media attention. This environment gave Shanaya visibility and an informal stamp of “belonging” in the Bollywood ecosystem, even without any professional work to her name.

Even before proving herself on the big screen, Shanaya was given opportunities that are typically reserved for well-established celebrities — such as high-budget brand endorsements and features in popular music videos. But this visibility came at a cost. She was widely trolled for her awkward expressions and poor Hindi during these early appearances, which raised doubts about her readiness for acting. Instead of being sent to an acting school or focusing on rigorous performance training, it is speculated that her family prioritized cosmetic enhancements at a very young age. Before-and-after images of Shanaya suggest a significant transformation in her facial features, which many believe has contributed to her lack of natural expressions — a major concern for any aspiring actor.

Despite claiming in interviews that she worked hard to improve her acting and dancing skills during the years her debut was delayed, audiences are not seeing those improvements reflected in her performances. Her dance videos, meant to showcase her skill and expressive range, have largely fallen flat, with many viewers criticizing her for a lack of expression and stiff movements — both possibly linked to the cosmetic procedures she underwent at a young age.

Adding to the controversy is the curious behavior of her co-star Vikrant Massey. Known for his subtle, nuanced acting and deep filmography, Vikrant raised eyebrows by going out of his way to heap praise on Shanaya during the film’s promotional events. In interview after interview, Vikrant complimented Shanaya’s dedication, talent, and growth as an actor — to the point that some viewers felt it was being done under pressure. One particular statement — that he “learned a lot from her” and that she was “better than him” — sounded so exaggerated that it led to criticism from even his loyal fans. While it’s understandable for co-stars to support each other, such overly flattering remarks have made many question Vikrant’s authenticity and intentions.

This behavior has not gone unnoticed by the public. Social media reactions point out that if seasoned actors like Vikrant Massey begin blindly supporting unproven star kids, they risk losing the trust of their fan base. After all, actors like Vikrant are often seen as the face of talent-based success in Bollywood — individuals who rose through the ranks not because of their last names but because of their hard work and skill. For them to be seen endorsing nepotism without critical judgment could dilute their own brand and alienate their core supporters.

Shanaya’s entry into the film industry also reflects a larger trend: casting star kids opposite talented outsiders. This seems to be a calculated move by producers. Since audiences are unlikely to buy tickets solely for a star kid’s performance, casting them alongside critically acclaimed actors — such as Vikrant Massey or Adarsh Gourav — creates a safety net. These actors can carry the emotional weight of a film and provide credibility, while the star kid benefits from the association. Sara Ali Khan and Janhvi Kapoor have similarly been paired with talented outsiders to improve their films’ appeal. This strategy reveals a certain lack of faith in the star kids’ standalone draw and suggests an awareness of the growing public demand for genuine talent.

Even Shanaya’s claim that she focused on honing her craft while waiting for the right opportunity is being questioned. If she truly worked on her acting and dancing for years, why is it not evident in her performances? Why are her expressions still being criticized? Why does her dialogue delivery seem unconvincing? These are valid questions, especially when such narratives are used to overshadow the real struggles of thousands of talented but underprivileged aspiring actors who lack even a fraction of the opportunities Shanaya has received.

Shanaya’s PR team, along with her parents, seems intent on framing her story as one of perseverance and hard work. But the selective disclosure of facts and an unwillingness to acknowledge her privileges only makes the audience more skeptical. Instead of letting her work speak for itself, there’s a visible push to control the narrative even before the public forms its own opinions. The desperation to declare her as a “brilliant actor” before the audience has even watched her debut film reflects a broader problem in the industry — the lack of humility and patience when it comes to earning public trust.

The film industry is changing. Audiences are more vocal, aware, and discerning than ever before. They no longer accept mediocrity packaged with glamour. If star kids like Shanaya want to be taken seriously, they will have to do more than just exist within the system — they’ll have to earn their place, prove their worth, and respect the audience’s intelligence. Similarly, actors like Vikrant Massey, who are held in high regard for their sincerity and talent, must stay true to their values and fan base. Supporting a co-star is one thing; compromising on integrity is another.

Ultimately, Shanaya Kapoor’s debut has become more of a media spectacle than a celebration of talent. Whether she manages to prove herself in the long run remains to be seen. But for now, her journey serves as a reminder of how privilege, when unchecked, can sometimes do more harm than good — both for the privileged and those around them.

Play video :
https://youtu.be/DUr163wgboM?si=V9MYPKce09TUUtO1